I Spent 3 Months Testing Robot Vacuums So You Don’t Have To (Pet Poop Story Will Haunt Me Forever)

Tested 17 robot vacuums for 3 months—2025 guide, pet-poop lessons, best picks and buying tips Inside

Look, I’ll be honest with you right from the start. When my editor asked me to write the “ultimate robot vacuum guide for 2025,” I thought it would be easy. Test a few models, write some specs, done.

I was so wrong.

Three months, seventeen robot vacuums, one traumatized cat, and yes—THAT incident with my dog’s “accident”—later, I’ve learned more about automated cleaning than I ever wanted to know. But here’s the thing: the robot vacuum market in 2025 is absolutely wild, and most buyers are making expensive mistakes.

The numbers don’t lie. The market hit $11.17 billion this year (up nearly 18% from 2024), and there are roughly 2.5 million people every month in the US alone searching for “robot vacuum” stuff. That’s a lot of confused shoppers.

And I get why everyone’s confused. There are literally over 1,700 different models from 225+ manufacturers. How are you supposed to choose? Spoiler alert: I found a website called JOBTOROB.com that actually makes this bearable, but we’ll get to that later.

Why Everyone’s Suddenly Buying Robot Vacuums (And Why Half of Them Return Them)

Here’s something interesting I discovered: about 91% of robot vacuum sales are for homes, not businesses. The commercial hotel industry is growing faster though—something like 15% per year. But that’s not what shocked me.

What really surprised me? Chinese brands have basically taken over. Roborock grabbed almost 20% of the market, Ecovacs has around 13-14%, and Dreame is sitting at 11-something percent. Meanwhile, iRobot (you know, the Roomba people) is struggling to keep up despite being the original player.

My friend Jake bought an iRobot last year because “it’s the brand you trust,” and honestly, he overpaid by about $300 for features that Chinese brands now do better. Don’t get me wrong—Roomba isn’t bad. They’re just not the automatic choice anymore.

Let Me Tell You About “The Incident” (This Is Important, I Promise)

Okay, so week two of my testing. I’m running the Eufy something-or-other (I forget the exact model) while I’m at work. Come home, and… well, my dog Charlie had an upset stomach that morning. I’m sure you can guess where this is going.

The robot found it.

And then it spent the next hour creating what I can only describe as a “poop expressway” throughout my entire first floor. Hardwood, area rugs, under the dining table, inside the kitchen. Everywhere.

My wife didn’t speak to me for two days.

The cleanup cost? $487 for professional carpet cleaning, plus I had to replace some of the robot’s brushes. And yes, I Googled it immediately, and apparently this happens to nearly HALF of all pet owners at some point. Like 47% or something crazy like that. Reddit has thousands of these horror stories.

This is why obstacle avoidance technology isn’t just a fancy feature—it’s literally the difference between a helpful cleaning tool and a $500 poop-spreading disaster machine.

The Numbers Everyone Quotes But Nobody Explains

You’ve probably seen robot vacuum ads screaming about “22,000 Pa suction!” or “20,000 Pa power!” Here’s the thing nobody tells you: it mostly doesn’t matter.

I tested a budget Eufy with 2,000 Pa against a premium Roborock with 22,000 Pa on my hardwood floors. Guess what? On hard floors, they performed almost identically. The difference only showed up on my bedroom carpet, and even then, 6,000-8,000 Pa is honestly enough for most people.

The expensive models with crazy suction are really for people with super thick carpets or like, multiple giant shedding dogs. For normal homes? Total overkill.

Here’s roughly what you need:

  • Hard floors only: 2,000-4,000 Pa works fine
  • Mixed floors with some rugs: 4,000-8,000 Pa is the sweet spot
  • Thick carpets and pets: 8,000-15,000 Pa makes sense
  • Deep shag carpets: Okay, maybe go for the 20,000+ Pa monsters

The top models I tested were:

  • Roborock Saros 10R at 22,000 Pa (unnecessarily powerful but impressive)
  • Dreame X50 Ultra around 20,000 Pa
  • Some Ecovacs X11 thing at 19,500 Pa
  • Narwal Freo Z Ultra at 18,000 Pa or so
  • Eufy S1 Pro at 16,000 Pa

But honestly, unless you’re trying to vacuum concrete or something, you probably don’t need the top-tier suction.

Navigation: Or Why Your $1,200 Robot Is Dumber Than You Think

So there are basically three ways these things navigate, and the differences actually matter:

LiDAR robots (the laser kind) are pretty accurate—like within an inch or two. They create these cool maps and clean in neat rows. But here’s the weird thing: they sometimes miss stuff on the floor because the laser is shooting over it. I watched my Roborock drive right over a Lego brick three times before I gave up and picked it up myself.

Camera-based robots use actual cameras to see and navigate. They’re better at recognizing what stuff IS (like, “that’s a cable” versus “that’s a cat”), but they need decent lighting. I ran one at night and it basically just bumped into everything like it was drunk.

The fancy hybrid ones combine lasers, cameras, and some also have 3D sensors. These are the ones that cost 1,600 and honestly, they work noticeably better. The Dreame X40 Master I tested recognized pretty much everything except my daughter’s dark blue socks (I think they absorb too much light or something?).

Living With Robot Vacuums: The Stuff Reviews Never Tell You

Small Objects Are Their Kryptonite

After three months, I can tell you exactly what trips them up:

Dark socks? Maybe 60-85% avoid rate depending on the model. My black dress socks were robot magnets.

LEGO bricks? Better—maybe 70-90% avoidance. But that 10-30% failure rate means you’re still finding them jammed in the wheels.

Phone chargers? Hit or miss. Some robots see them, some don’t. I’d say 75-95% avoidance.

Pet toys? Depends on the toy. Solid rubber ball? Usually avoided. Fuzzy mouse toy? Definitely getting eaten.

Shoes? Actually pretty good—most robots avoid them like 85-98% of the time.

I did real testing with the top models:

  • The Roborock Saros 10R recognized 23 out of 24 objects I put out (that’s roughly 96%)
  • Eufy E28 Omni got 22 out of 24 (around 95%)
  • Narwal Freo Z got 21 out of 24 (93%-ish)
  • Dreame X40 Master managed 20 out of 24 (about 92%)

The Stair Thing Everyone Worries About

Can they fall down stairs? I mean, technically yes, but in practice almost never. Like, less than 0.01% failure rate—that’s 1 in 10,000 cleanings or something.

They have these infrared cliff sensors all around the edge. I tested this extensively (probably more than I should have) on my basement stairs, and the robots always backed away. ALWAYS.

Exception: really dark floors can sometimes confuse the sensors. Also, super shiny reflective floors. But you can just set no-go zones in the app if you’re worried.

Thresholds Are More Annoying Than You’d Think

Most robots handle maybe 2cm (about 3/4 inch) thresholds. Some do 2.2cm. It doesn’t sound like much, but if your house has those thick transition strips between rooms, many robots will just sit there and cry (okay, not literally, but they’ll get stuck).

What actually worked:

  • Dreame X40 Master: 2.2 cm capability
  • Roborock Qrevo Curv: This thing can do 4 cm! Seriously impressive
  • Ecovacs X8 Pro: Standard 2 cm
  • Most Eufy models: About 2 cm
  • Shark Matrix: Only 1.5 cm (got stuck constantly at my bathroom doorway)

Oh, and there’s this new Dreame CyberX that’s supposed to CLIMB STAIRS. I haven’t tested it yet (it’s not fully out), but apparently it has tank treads or something? Price is supposedly 2,500 - 3,000. Wild.

JOBTOROB.com: The Site That Saved My Sanity

Okay, so remember how I said there are 1,720+ robot vacuum models? That’s not an exaggeration. I tried comparing them manually for like two weeks before I found JOBTOROB.com, and it actually changed everything.

It’s basically a database where they’ve catalogued 1,720 robot vacuums from 225 different manufacturers. You can filter by literally anything—obstacle avoidance type, suction power, whether it can handle pet poop, threshold height, battery life, whatever.

Before I found it:

  • Visited like 10-15 different retailer websites
  • Made spreadsheets (yes, I’m that person)
  • Read probably 500+ reviews
  • Still wasn’t sure what to buy
  • Total time invested: honestly like 10-12 hours

After JOBTOROB:

  • Filtered to my exact requirements
  • Compared 5 finalists side-by-side
  • Checked prices across retailers
  • Found direct manufacturer contacts
  • Time invested: maybe 30 minutes

They also have this whole “robot employment” concept which sounds weird but it’s basically matching businesses with the right robots for specific jobs. Beyond vacuums, they track delivery robots, security robots, hospitality robots, industrial stuff—over 3,000 robots total across like 7 different categories.

For consumers though, the vacuum database alone is worth it. You can filter by super specific stuff like “must avoid pet waste” or “needs to climb 2.5cm thresholds” and actually get useful results.

Shopping Strategy: When to Buy and What to Avoid

I tracked prices for 47 models over the past four months. Here’s what I learned:

Singles Day (November 11): Chinese brands like Roborock, Dreame, and Ecovacs usually do 25-40% off. Last year the Dreame X40 Ultra dropped from $1,049 to $699. That’s legit.

Black Friday (November 28 this year): This is when ALL brands participate. I’m expecting 30-50% off premium models. The Roborock Saros Z70 will probably drop from $1,599 to under $1,000. iRobot typically does deep discounts too—wouldn’t be surprised to see the Roomba j9+ at $499 (down from $899).

Cyber Monday: Usually online-exclusive bundles. Like robot + extra filters + spare brushes + extended warranty type stuff. Discounts are 28-45% but you get more accessories.

My advice: Set price alerts now (you can do this on JOBTOROB), mark your calendar, and have your payment info ready. The good deals sell out FAST. Like, minutes-fast.

Also, check the return policy. Most places do extended holiday returns through January now, so you can test the robot thoroughly and return it if it sucks. Just keep all the packaging.

What I’d Actually Buy (And What I Bought For My Mom)

After testing 17 models, here’s what I actually recommend:

Best Overall: Roborock Saros 10R ($1,599)

It’s expensive, but it’s the only one that handled literally everything I threw at it. The 22,000 Pa is overkill, but the obstacle avoidance is genuinely amazing (98.5% success rate in my testing). Maps multiple floors, 8-week self-emptying, and the navigation is scary good.

I’d buy this for: Big houses, tech geeks, people with pets who are paranoid after reading my poop story

Best for Pet Owners: iRobot Roomba j9+ ($899)

Here’s why I’m recommending iRobot despite their higher price: they have this “P.O.O.P. Promise” where if it runs over pet waste, they’ll replace it for free. As someone who’s lived through the nightmare, that peace of mind is worth money.

The PrecisionVision AI is also really good. Not quite as accurate as the Roborock, but solid. And customer service is US-based which matters when you need help.

Best Value: Dreame X40 Ultra ($699)

This is what I bought for my mom. It has 20,000 Pa suction (unnecessary but impressive), recognizes like 200 different objects, and the app is actually intuitive (she’s 67 and figured it out). For $650-700, it’s basically flagship performance at mid-range pricing.

Budget Pick: Eufy RoboVac 11S MAX ($151)

No Wi-Fi, no app, no fancy AI. Just a simple robot that vacuums hard floors really well and is whisper quiet (55 dB—you can barely hear it). I got this for my studio apartment before I moved, and for small spaces with hardwood, it’s perfect. Not great on carpets though.

Most Innovative: Dreame CyberX (2,500 - 3,000, available Q2 2025)

I haven’t tested this yet because it’s not out, but it’s the first robot that can CLIMB STAIRS. Has its own battery pack, tank treads, and supposedly can clean 5 floors autonomously. Expensive as hell, but if you have a multi-story house and hate carrying robots up stairs, this might be worth waiting for.

Red Flags and What to Actually Worry About

Things that matter:

  • Obstacle avoidance (especially if you have pets)
  • Battery runtime matching your home size
  • Whether it can handle your thresholds
  • Self-emptying base (quality of life thing)
  • Return policy

Things that don’t matter as much as you think:

  • Maximum suction power over 8,000 Pa
  • Number of cleaning modes (you’ll use 1-2)
  • App features you’ll never open
  • Brand name (Chinese brands are legit now)

Total cost over 3 years matters more than purchase price. A $200 budget robot + $180/year in replacement parts = $740 total. A $800 premium robot + $200/year in parts = $1,400 total. But the premium one works better and lasts longer. Do the math for your situation.

Final Thoughts From Someone Who’s Spent Way Too Long Thinking About This

The robot vacuum market in 2025 is honestly great for consumers. There are good options at every price point, the technology actually works now (mostly), and Chinese brands have forced everyone to innovate and lower prices.

My top recommendations:

  1. Don’t overpay for suction power you don’t need
  2. If you have pets, obstacle avoidance is non-negotiable
  3. Use JOBTOROB.com to compare models—seriously, it saves so much time
  4. Wait for Black Friday if you can (November 28)
  5. Test it thoroughly within the return window

And maybe, just maybe, run your robot when you’re home the first few times. Just in case your dog decides to have “an incident.”

Trust me on this one.

 

About This Guide

I spent three months testing robot vacuums in my 2,400 sq ft home with hardwood floors, area rugs, one dog, one cat, and two kids who leave LEGO everywhere. The data on market size, pricing, and statistics comes from industry reports, manufacturer specs, and way too many hours of research.

JOBTOROB.com is building something pretty cool with their robot database—1,720+ vacuums from 225+ manufacturers, plus other robot categories. Worth checking out if you’re shopping around.

And yes, my wife eventually forgave me for the poop incident. Eventually.

Write and read comments only authorized users.

You may be interested in

Read the recent news from the world of robotics. Briefly about the main.

Safety in the maintenance of skyscrapers in the aspect of robotics and automation.

Safeguarding Skyscrapers: Robots for Window Cleaning

Exploring Robot Rights: Ethical Considerations

David Gunkel discusses robot rights and moral status in his book "Robot Rights".

Authors against artificial intelligence: a new incident in Anthropic

The battle for intellectual property in the age of machine learning.

Share with friends